Las Islas Malvinas son una dependencia británica en el Atlántico Sur cerca de Argentina.
Apart from the poor Spanish, on which I have no competency to judge, I do not see a problem with the name of the archipelago. Some may have a problem with the meaning of the sentence, but that is not what I am addressing here. In English we would of course say: The Falkland Islands are a British dependency in the South Atlantic near Argentina.
When we put ‘The United Kingdom is part of an archipelago off the west coast of Europe. ‘ into Spanish it would be nonsense to say ‘El United Kingdom es parte de un archipiélago frente a la costa oeste de Europa.’ Even the English expect to hear: El Reino Unido es parte de un archipiélago frente a la costa oeste de Europa.
So a document produced by the EU, in respect of a primarily Spanish speaker conference making refence to the south sea archipelago by both its name in Spanish and in English is nothing about which to get hot under the collar, is it? Or am I missing something?
Actually, I think we should take the EU to task, for the actual words are: ‘over the Islas Malvinas / Falkland Islands’ on two points. The word order is incorrect, unless F comes before I in the EU alphabet, and the article is incorrect. The correct names are The Falkland Islands and Las Islas Malvinas. The Islas Malvinas is an abomination, deserving of no place either in the Spanish language or the English.
Finally we note that:
in the Spanish language version, which is entirely expected, the English language name of the archipelago is omitted.
in the French language version we have a reference to les Îles Malouines/Îles Falkland, which is perhaps also expected as it is well known that the French, apart from de Gaulle do not know whether to say Oui ou Non (with apologies to my French friends)
in the Portuguese language version we have as Ilhas Malvinas / Ilhas Falkland, which is really quite confusing considering the close relationship between the Spanish and Portuguese tongues.
For further information refer to:
- BBC article: Rishi Sunak hits out at EU calling Falklands Islands ‘Islas Malvinas’
- European Council webpage: EU_CELAC summit July 2023
- Declaration webpage: Declaration of the EU-CELAC Summit 2023, 17-18 July 2023
- Declaration PDF in English
- PDF in French
- PDF in Portuguese
- PDF in Spanish